Skip to content
Is there an AI for this?

FDE ACADEMY · MODULE 04 · LESSON 02

Residency, transfer, and the questions that follow

Where data rests, where it is processed, and where the logs are. Two jurisdictions treated side by side, because the transfer question has a different shape in each.

Effort
About ninety minutes of reading and note-taking.
Skills
compliance-governance · security-hardening

Free and self-paced. No certification is offered.

Before you startYou have completed lesson 01 and can distinguish a legal requirement from a recommended practice.


01Three different “wheres”

At rest: which storage, in which region. In transit and in use: which systems process it, and where those run. And the one that gets missed — telemetry, logs, error reports and support access, which frequently leave a region that the primary data never does.

Ask the third question explicitly of any hosted service. A vendor can hold your documents in-region and still have support engineers elsewhere able to see them, and that is a fact about the arrangement rather than a defect in it.


02Tenancy is not residency

Deploying into your own cloud account in a chosen region gives you control and a location. It does not by itself make the arrangement domestic: the provider is still a processor, its own supply chain still exists, and the contractual questions still have to be answered. Module 03 lesson 02 made the same point from the architecture side; here it is the paperwork side of it.

Write down which of the three “wheres” each design decision fixes, and which it leaves open. Most disputes in a security review are two people answering different ones of the three.


03Different jurisdictions, different shapes

The transfer question does not have one universal form. In some jurisdictions there is a statutory mechanism to satisfy; in others the relevant provision is not in force, and the work becomes contractual and evidential instead — due diligence, terms modelled on the regulator’s published clauses, and a security assessment of the receiving environment.

Do not carry an answer across a border. Read the jurisdiction page for the customer you are serving, note the status of each instrument and its date, and treat anything you learned elsewhere as a question rather than an answer.


04Do this

PRACTICAL TASK

Compare the transfer question in two jurisdictions

Read the framework and regulations sections for two jurisdictions and write, for one hosted vendor, what a transfer would require in each.

What you need

  • No hardware. Two hours and somewhere to write.

Steps

  1. 01

    Read the framework section for Hong Kong and note the status of each instrument, including anything marked as not in operation.

    Hong Kong — framework

  2. 02

    Read the framework section for the European Union and note where the shape of the question differs.

    European Union — framework

  3. 03

    Pick one hosted vendor and read the same tool’s assessment in both jurisdictions, including everything each page says it could not determine.

    Claude in the European Union

  4. 04

    Write the three “wheres” for that vendor: at rest, in processing, and in telemetry or support. Mark each as known from a published document, or unknown.

  5. 05

    Finish with the questions you would send the vendor. Aim for five that a published page could not answer.

You are done when

  • You can state how the transfer question differs in shape between the two jurisdictions, with the instrument names.
  • Your three “wheres” each say known or unknown, and the known ones name the document.
  • Five vendor questions, none of which is answered by anything the vendor has already published.

05Where these facts live

This lesson does not restate anything that is already recorded with its evidence elsewhere on the site. These are the pages it leans on.

  • European Union

    Instruments, statuses and dates, with the primary sources each was read from.

  • How we research

    Why a vendor publishing a page is a fact, and what the page says is a claim that still needs verifying.

  • AI-assisted candidate workflow

    Residency and transfer decided inside one design, in a jurisdiction where the activity itself is regulated.

Ticks are stored in your browser only. They are not sent anywhere, they are not attached to an account, and clearing your browser data removes them.